Am I mad to sell a house for £30K less than market value ? Exploring the Perception of Value

I just sold my late mums house in 9 days for nearly about £30k less than I could have made … am I mad ?

 

Let’s see ….

 

 

It is always a chore and slow to wind up someone’s estate. Even though my mum had a simple estate and everything in line (I know as I looked after her finances) it just takes an age. The biggest challenge and stress is selling the house though as we (sellers) are never in control.

That is, we are not in control in England as the buyers have all the cards. In Scotland there is a different legal system so an offer made and accepted is a partial contract giving a liability (I think it is 10%) against any party pulling out …. boy would that have been handy.

Now mum lived in a simple 2 bed bungalow in a nice quiet part of town close to the outskirts and fields. An idea retirement place that I rather forced her to buy when dad died. The house she and dad had lived in for 33 years was both too big for her and every single thing held a memory of her and dad’s life. You could just feel the inner sadness at every triggered memory. So my brother & I contrived a plan to get her out so she could build fresh memories.

Some resistance, a few home truths and finally when done, mum was very happy and glad she moved … result !

 

So … the Context of the Sell

The situation I found myself in 2 weeks ago, well here is the chronology:

    • After probate granted, the house went on the market around the middle of June.
    • Sold day 1 to the first person – a little old lady who had tried and failed twice to buy the identical house next door… so she really wanted it !
    • Day 10, the persons buyer (for her house) found to have fraudulent monies so sale off. We really felt for the old lady
    • Back on the market and sold 3 days later to a cash buyer and I accepted a decent discount for a ‘quick’ cash sale. Their daughter had a trust fund maturing early august and they wanted her to buy a house. So really I thought, 5/6 weeks and done.

… this is where is started to go wrong !! Seems no one verified how long the trust fund would take to release the money (despite my questions). They told me ‘straight after’ as that is what they thought but did not know – lazy estate agents for you

    • drag drag and excuses later we are in the 2nd week of September and the buyer suddenly decided to have a survey they had not done and was not needed. Following this (and nothing wrong) they decided to pull out for no reason the day before exchange of contracts.

… Ggggrrrr

    • Six days later sold again to someone wanting a quick sale (they had a chain ready to go).
    • 10 days after this (they moved quickly) with the surveys done, mortgages in place and contracts drawn up and ready to exchange they pulled out (seems a house they really wanted came back on the market so they jumped)

AAAhhhhhhgggggggg !!!!

Can anyone spot why the English system is so bad !

    • Over the next 2 weeks a few viewings but critically the number of similar properties in the town more than doubled, i.e. a few trying to move before Christmas and maybe sensing a market slump coming, and there is a palpable fall off in online activity.

So despite selling within a few days of each time going onto market, despite there being no issues at all with the house…. events rather conspired. And worse, the UK furlough system ends shortly, an army of people are about to loose their jobs, businesses are crashing all over and no one wants to move unless they have to. So I was faced with a few realities:

    1. I was unlikely to sell and complete inside a 6 month window as no one really moves in the UK from December to March, and more likely a 9-10 month one taking me to May or June of next year. It was not a price issue, but a lack of buyer issue.
    2. At this point the house would have been empty for 15-18 months – not a good place to be in any property. Houses need to breath and get airflow, the garden maintained and there was always the risk of vandalism and squatters.
    3. I would have to pay all the utilities and taxes for that time. Even though not much was being used the standing charges add up. I also had to keep the insurance going (with the unoccupied restrictions carry some greater liabilities).
    4. If we had a bad storm and there was damage, it would be days before it was known and I would be liable for the repairs

So lots of negatives, lots of liabilities and a very uncertain sale point. In parallel to this we had arranged our finances in anticipation of completion, so to unwind that and re-start putting the pension fund withdrawals back on was a phaff I really did not want.

Then the brainwave …

…. I wonder if I could sell to a Quick Move agent ?

(These are companies that buy almost anything but at a discount to fair market value. The discount ranges depending on the company, market and how ‘sharp’ they are from 60% to 85% of fair value with a typical price being in the mid to high 70%’s)

So … a bit of web research, some reviews read and a look at Companies House into the company financials and history and very quickly settled on one company. They had been in business for over 20 years, solid track record.

The whole process could only have been quicker if their surveyor had not been so busy. From initial enquiry to cash in my bank was 10 days (and could easily have been 4 or 5).

But really … was I mad, desperate or shrewd ?

 

The numbers

    • House had a realistic expectation of around £170K
    • I sold for £138K.

.… did I really loose a possible £32K ? ….. no !

There are really 3 options available

1. Sell (very quickly in a normal market)

Clearly this is not happening. The time wasting chump with his daughters trust fund rather scuppered it all really.

2. Sell very slowly in a normal but subdued market

This is the most probable option if I just left things.

This option it takes months to sell. No one buys a house in the UK really much from November to March and the type of house is really a retirement home. People of that age move only if they have too and a pandemic with economic turmoil would not be high on the list. So I can expect costs like the Utilities, Taxes, any Maintenance and insurance etc. I can also expect that in a depressed market a much lower offer and achievable price.

 

3. Sell to a quick move agent in a few days

Wow .. what an apparent financial hit .. but over in days !

 

In Summary

Now option (1) is dead. It just is not realistically gonna happen, so really it is the variable difference of time and some costs that determines the effective cash difference over the next 6-9 months. I estimated the difference to range from £12k to £21K.

This is not that big in the grand scheme – less than 10% of my total inheritance in the worst case

Note also I say ‘Perceived’ Loss. It is an illusion to think I (or you) loose anything. You never had it in the first place and this is the biggest lesson in this. The focus some have on what they see as getting a few quid more is just barking mad.

What I really should be saying is that my risk is up to £21K over a 6-9 month time frame and how much is that risk worth to me ?

    • Stress & Worry
    • Variable Liabilities
    • Managing cash flows I had not planned
    • Less than 10% of my inheritance
  •  

Then there is my pension fund. There is the opportunity costs of taking monies out of my pension fund I had not planned to. The rate I would need meant I would need to take £20K-£30k to cover that time period.

So the way I looked at it was this:

      1. Take a discount of £12k-£21K on what I would achieve in a few months and have zero risk

OR

2.  Hang on for maybe £21K more and incur a £20k-£30K loss on my pension fund due to withdrawal

As can easily be seen, option (2) gives at best a cost neutral position and at worse at least a £10K deficit position and all for what.. a lot of stress, worry, travel back and forth long distance and the rest.

 

This really was a 10 second decision !

 

There is more Icing on the cake

I have an investment that is about to pop and really wanted to buy more stock. So within 10 mins of receiving the funds, I had put the max (£40k) into our ISA’s and bought … the bubbling is getting louder and as I write, The value of that £40k has increased 31% in less than 4 days. It will not really be long until the paper loss is covered.

So I win both ways –  No stress de-risking my liabilities and outgoings, and I make up the paper loss quickly… winner winner chicken dinner for two please !

 

Lessons by looking at the Bigger Picture

    • Stop looking at the ‘one’ transaction – the decision is about a portfolio of outcomes.

Far too many people focus on one immediate transaction. They forget that financial decision making is about a portfolio of possible outcomes.

    • Net Worth is not what you perceive as the ‘value’, but rather about a realisable value

The more illiquid an asset is, the bigger the discount to perceived value you need to consider. It is no good thinking you live is a £400k house if you need the cash quickly you might only get £350K.

    • This is not a contrived or unique example and is just as applicable to selling a car

Say you had a car you felt you sell for £10K. You needed a quick sale to pay for something else. Do you hang on or accept £9k. On paper it looks like you loose 10%, but this is an illusion – you never had it in the first place. Is £1K even significant or just noise and pride.

    • Only cash in hand has a fixed value, everything else is a perceived value.

Your choice is to accept the lower price because you value something else more, assess the price of the risk as too high, or hang on and see but with no guarantee you would achieve what you perceive as the true value.

 

I would offer this maxims based on my experience

    • When faced with an investment decision, a disposal decision, or a large purchase decision…. look at the bigger picture. It is never about a single cost or price

 

2 comments

  1. How very interesting- and much the same experience, ish, when my parents sold their parent’s home. It was painful, took months, multiple buyers, etc. What seemed strange, is the lack of time actually on the market- just the rest of the time taken doing the paperwork. Oh how I wish for a more simple system, that takes, say, 2-4 weeks, than any longer. People would move more, and houses would actually be more sensibly priced (well, maybe that last point is just a fantasy).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *